We Got Paid by Insurance Companies. I Wish We'd Built the Whole Business Around It.

We sold it. It made great money. And I'd build it completely differently today.

We built a short-term rental business from scratch.

Zero units to over 25.

We ran it for three years.

Then we sold it.

It made great money.

But if I had to do it all over again, I'd barely touch the market everyone is chasing.

Vacationers.

Instead, I'd go straight to the one almost nobody talks about.

The one where the tenant is a family whose house is being rebuilt.

And the one paying the rent is an insurance company.

Let me show you how we got there.

The model was simpler than you think

Most people picture short-term rentals as buying a beach house and listing it online.

That's not what we did.

We used something called rental arbitrage.

We rented houses and apartments. Then all we did was furnish them.

That's it. We didn't own the real estate.

Here's what the numbers looked like:

  • Setup cost per unit (furniture and setup): somewhere between $15,000 and $30,000

  • Income: around $800 a month per bedroom

  • Growth: from zero to over 25 units in about 18 months

That's fast.

But speed isn't the lesson. The lesson is why it worked, and what almost broke it.

The two things that made it work

There were two things that made this business work for us.

1. We had an operator who ran it.

We weren't involved in the day-to-day. Someone else handled the guests, the cleaning and the problems.

2. We could market it from our own channels.

We already had an audience. Most people just don't have that when they're starting out.

Be honest with yourself here.

If you don't have an operator and you don't have a way to fill the units, you're not buying the same business we bought.

You're buying a job.

The part nobody tells you

Here's what no one tells you when they sell you on the short-term rental business.

The vacation side is brutal.

Here was our real problem: we were not in a vacation market.

So when people weren't traveling, we had big swings of low occupancy.

That was super hard.

And even when the units were full, there was a different problem.

In a normal short-term rental, somebody new is using the place constantly. That means constant turnover.

For every single guest, you're going back in to replace:

  • Toilet paper and paper towels

  • The little snacks

  • All the supplies

  • All the cleaning things

Over and over and over again.

The property is fine. It's the churn that eats you up.

The niche that made us the most money

Knowing those details, if I had to build that entire business all over again, I'd build it around one niche.

The stays that made us the most money weren't vacationers at all.

They were families whose homes were being renovated, or had flooded.

They were displaced. They needed a temporary place to live until their house was ready.

When that happens, the insurance company pays you to put them in your place.

And they pay you for three, four, five months. However long it takes.

Think about what that does to the business:

  • You get paid for months over one stretch

  • There's no turnover

  • You're not going in every few days replacing supplies

  • Someone is living there steadily

So you keep more of the money.

That's the market.

And here's the embarrassing part: we found it almost by accident. We never built around it on purpose.

What I'd do differently today

So if I were rebuilding this today, here's exactly what I'd do.

I'd stop fighting the vacation swings entirely.

I'd go straight for properties that fit the replacement housing market. Families in between homes. Insurance companies paying the bill.

That's the whole change.

One decision. Different business.

How we got out without the headaches

And when it came time to leave, I'd do exactly what we did.

We sold the business to our operator.

We let the operator pay us over time through owner financing.

So we kept getting paid, without owning the business anymore and without any of the headaches.

If you're building something an operator runs, think about your exit on day one. The person running it might be your best buyer.

The lesson under all of this

Everyone is chasing the exciting version of the short-term rental business.

The beach house. The five-star reviews. The weekend bookings.

But the money was in the boring, steady version the whole time.

That's true of a lot more than rentals.

The exciting deal is the one everyone talks about. The steady one is the one that actually sets you free.

If you want to learn how we pick deals like this, and how to build passive income greater than your monthly expenses, come join us live.

👉 Register for the free Passive Income Lab Masterclass here (Mondays at 8pm ET)

And if you want to see the whole breakdown in three minutes, the full video is here.

Stop chasing the exciting money. Chase the steady money.

Talk soon,

Russ Morgan

Wealth Without Wall Street

P.S. Inside the Passive Income Lab Masterclass, Joey and I walk through how we vet deals now, so you build around what actually works instead of finding it by accident like we did. It's free, every Monday at 8pm ET. Save your seat here

P.P.S. Want to see how close your cash flow is to actually setting you free? Take the free 2-minute Financial Freedom Quiz. And if you missed it, here's the full story of this same short-term rental business: $288,000 of income, and why it still fails our Golden Filter. Read it here

DISCLOSURE: Wealth Without Wall Street provides educational and informational content only and does not provide legal, tax, financial, or investment advice. Any examples or case studies are illustrative and not a promise or guarantee of results. Earnings or income statements (if any) are not typical, and your results will vary based on factors such as your effort, experience, market conditions, and business decisions. You are responsible for your own actions and outcomes.

You can also read this article on our Substack.

Listen to our Podcast!